So what’s that one book that everyone raved about, that you spent $20 on the hardcover to purchase or twelve weeks on the library waiting list to receive, that you opened with excited anticipation… only to finish and wonder what all of the hullabaloo was about?
For me, it was Life of Pi. When I turned the last page and set the book down, I thought, “I want my two hours back.” Or maybe I expended three or four. I don’t know. I’ve tried to block it out like a humiliating high school memory or the knowledge that your parents had sex.
But I do know that I was not interested in the story, and I kept reading because I thought, “Surely it must get better because everyone is talking about how great this novel is!” To my mind, not only did it not get better, it got worse with one of the lamest endings I’ve ever read.
Let me be clear. The author writes well. The book was well-crafted. But I am among those who need a character in a book that I can relate to or root for. No such person existed in The Life of Pi for me.
Also, showing that it is my opinion alone, everyone else in my book club liked the book. That did not, however, stop me from ranting about it at our meeting. (By the way, thanks for listening, book club friends, or at least pretending to listen while you played with your dessert or made a shopping list in your mind).
I recently picked up another strongly suggested read from an acquaintance and after a hundred pages tossed it back into the library book drop without once wondering what the characters might do next in the 600-page novel. I guess my taste just differed from my friend’s. It happens sometimes.
How many “amazing” books were what my kids would term an Epic Fail for you? What titles were rampantly recommended that turned out to be time-suckers or firecracker-duds?
Or have you recommended a book that you absolutely adored to someone who reported back that they didn’t like it at all? Why do you think that happened?
Round of Words in 80 Days Update: wrote 2,632 of 5,000 words this week; edited 81 of 186 pages in my middle-grade novel; trying out a new blogging goal of 3 times a week – Monday Mumblings, Wednesday Words, Friday Fiction (We’ll see how that goes!)